~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת נח
Parsha Stumpers
By: Daniel Listhaus
A Riddle:
סוף סוף ראשי 1.
תחילת סוף סופי
ויבא נח...אל
התבה
מי אני?ג
- (6:9) Where is there a remez
in the beginning of the parsha that Noach was not involved in
any of these three things?
- (6:9) Rashi brings down an
opinion that Noach was only great compared to those who lived in his
generation, but had he lived in Avraham’s generation he wouldn’t have been
anything remarkable. Why would we compare an individual to others? All
that should matter was if Noach was righteous based on expectations of him
alone, not based on what others are capable of?
- (6:13) How could the dor
ha'mabul be punished if there were no mitzvos yet? [Chizkuni]
- (6:13) Rashi writes that
because of the zenus of the generation, the gezairah (decree)
was that all mankind – good and bad – were to die. Why should the good
people be swept along with the bad?
- (6:13) Rashi says
that despite all the things that the dor ha'mabbul were doing, the gezairah
was sealed because of robbery. Why robbery more than avodah zarrah
or giluy arayos?
- (6:14) Why did Hashem have
Noach building the teivah specifically for 120 years and no more or
less?
- (6:14) According to Chizkuni
that there was a miracle that the tar on the outside didn’t get burned,
why couldn’t Hashem allow Noach’s teivah to be like Moshe’s with
only tar on the outside and double-dip on the already necessary neis for
either the outer tar not to get ruined in the hot water or for the
protective layer of cold water whyich surrounded the teivah to
separate it from the boiling water?
- (6:17) Why did Hashem punish
the world through means of a mabbul of water?
- (6:18) Rashi emphasizes the
two parts of the “bris” with Noach as a promise to keep the food from
spoiling and to protect him from the people who would try to kill him.
a. Why was the promise only needed to ensure that the
food stay good in the teivah?
b. Didn’t Hashem on His own want to stop the people
who dared threaten Noach (as Rashi says in 7;17)?
- (7:2) Even if Noach needed
to bring Karbanos after surviving the mabbul, why were 7 pairs of
each kosher animal necessary?
- (7:4) Why does Rashi refer
to the children of the adulterous unions at the time of the mabbul as
“mamzeirim”? Isn’t that specifically if the parents are Jewish?
- (7:7) Rashi both in
6:18 and 7:7 writes that it was forbidden to have marital relations in the
teivah. However, Rashi in 7:7 adds that the reason for this
was because the world was in a state of distress...
(a) Why does Rashi repeat himself? (b) Why does Rashi in 7:7 add the
reason? (c ) Why is this a valid reason? Clearly the people dying in the mabbul
deserved it. Shouldn't it have been considered a “joyous” time for the
world?
- (7:12) Where do we see from
this week's parsha that the day starts at night? Why is it that
there is a concept of miktzas hayom k'kulo only if the night is
part of the “miktzas”, yet if have even the full day without the
preceding night, this concept is not applicable?
- (7:17) The Torah uses the
phrase בעצם היום הזה in this week's parsha as well as three other times
in chumash in the same way. Where are these four times [Beraishis
7:17 ; Beraishis 17:37 ; Shemos 12:21 ; Devarim 32:48] and what is
the connection between them?
- (7:17-20 and 8:4) The teivah
was submerged 11 amos and the water came above the highest
mountains by 15 amos. It comes out that there was always a minimum
of 4 amos between the bottom of the teivah and the ground.
Why was this necessary? Do these 4 amos have a particular
significance?
- (7:23) Why did Og get Saved?
How did he survive being outside of the teivah?
- (7:23) Rashi writes that
about Noach it is written (Mishlei 11:31), “Behold the righteous
one is paid [punished] on earth” referring to the fact that he was bitten
by the lion in the teivah. What was he punished for?
- (8:7) Why did Noach
send out the raven and the dove? Why not just trust that Hashem would tell
him when to come out of the teivah?
- (8:8) Why did Noach
assume that if the dove found land that it wouldn’t return the teivah where
its species was?
- (8:10-11) The passukim
describe that the second time Noach sent out the dove, it came back with
an olive branch in its mouth. Rashi comments that the dove was
trying to tell Noach the following: “Better let my food be bitter as an
olive and provided by the hand of Hashem, and not sweet as honey but
provided by the hand of man...” (a) The dove should have had hakaras
hatov to Noach and his family. Why at the first opportunity does
the dove say such a remark? (b ) The dove's statement makes absolutely no
sense! The entire time Noach and the animals were in the teivah
they experienced open miracles. The whole teivah was something
which opposed teva. Wasn't it pretty apparent that Hashem was
present every step of the way?
- (8:14) Rashi writes
that the world needed a complete solar year of destruction,
yet Rashi said earlier (7:12 #2) that the first day didn’t count because
it wasn’t a complete day without the night before. If so, how was there a
complete year of destruction?
- (8:21) Surely Hashem
knew even before the mabbul that people are bad from youth. So,
either way – if that’s not a reason to destroy the world then why did
Hashem destroy it? And if it is a valid reason then why never again? What
changed? Also, what is the connection between this “decision” and the fact
that it seems to have been decided as a result of Hashem “smelling” the re’ach
hane’choach of Noach’s offering?
- (9:1) Why did Hashem need to
give Noach a beracha that the animals would fear him? Wasn't this
already built into the world from the sheishes y'mei beraishis?
- (9:9) Why did Hashem approve
of Noach’s necessity to demand a bris if Hashem had commanded him
already to have children in 9:1?
- (9:24) How did Noach know it
was Cham who dishonored him?
- (9:25) Did Noach do the
right thing by cursing Cna'an?
- (9:25-26) Why did Noach have
to curse Cham’s children to be slaves to his brother, and also bless Shem
that Cham be his slaves? Wouldn’t one of these be enough?
- (11:1) One of the reasons Rashi
gives as the reason behind why the dor haflaga began to build
the tower is because they thought that the world was on a cycle that every
1656 years Hashem wold bring another flood, so they wanted to be prepared
with supports for the skies. If so, why was Hashem so upset? Why not just
let the people think this incorrectly as long as they aren't bothering
anyone?
- If the dor haflaga wanted
to 'wage war' with Hashem, why did they buildמגדל בבל in a
valley? They should have built it on top of a mountain!?
- (11:28) Rashi brings down the story from the famous medrash
how Haran (Avraham's brother) stood and observed the episode of Avraham
being thrown into the fiery furnace. Haran decided that Avraham's fate
would determine his own faith in Hashem. The medrash continues that indeed
when Avraham emerged unscathed, Haran joined his side and was
consequentially thrown into the fire – and burned to death. What did Haran
do wrong? The Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo writes that Hashem does not
perform miracles for every kofeir that decides not to believe in
Hashem. This is why we have t he Torah and mitzvos which direct us
to remember Yetziyas Mitzrayim and Kriyas Yam Suf as a forever certificate
of Hashem's capabilities. Haran obviously lived before matan Torah and
kriyas yam suf, so what was so bad with him wanting to see Hashem perform
an open miracle first before fully believing in Hashem?