Friday, August 11, 2017

Parshas Eikev - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת עקב

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (7:12) Why does the parsha open with the word “v'haya” as opposed to “im” or just start with “eikev”?

  1. (7:21) Why does the Torah refer to Hashem here as “keil gadol v'nora” without the expression of “gibbur” as Moshe uses later in the parsha?

  1. (8:1) Rashi writes that deeds are attributed to those who complete it. As an example he brings that although it was Moshe who took charge of bringing Yosef Ha'Tzadik's bones out of Mitzrayim, the deed was attributed to B'nei Yisroel since they were the ones who ultimately brought the bones into Eretz Yisroel. Why is this “fair” that the full deed be attributed to the one who completed it despite the difference in proportion of effort put in and time spent?

  1. (8:4) The Torah and Rashi describe that Hashem promises that the feet of those walking barefoot will not swell. However in parshas Ki Savo (29:4) the Torah mentions the population having shoes that didn't wear out. Did they have shoes in the midbar or not?

  1. The passuk says, “Hear O Israel, today you cross the Jordan, to come and drive out nations greater and mightier than you...” Rashi comments “You are mighty, and they are mightier than you”. What is the purpose of this Rashi informing us that “we are mighty” before telling us the superior physical strength of the other nations? [And even if you want to answer like Rashi 11:23, still why does it have to be praise for the Emorim? Perhaps passuk is only saying that they are stronger than B'nei Yisroel as a reference for us to know that they are indeed stronger than us?]

  1. Moshe tells B'nei Yisroel that Hashem was furious with them having served the Eigel Ha'zahav and at Aharon in particular to the point that Hashem wanted to wipe out him and his descendents. Moshe then relates that his davening for them saved them. Rashi (9:20) comments that Moshe told them that his prayer was effective to atone for half; for only two of Aharon's sons died, while two were left. How could we understand this Rashi?


  1. (11:20) The passuk mentions that we should swear by Hashem's name. How does this reconcile with with the passuk (Devarim 5:11) in the aseres ha'dibros which prohibits swearing by Hashems name for no reason?

Friday, July 28, 2017

Parshas Devarim - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת דברים
Parsha Stumpers


By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (1:3) Rashi offers four reasons why Moshe rabbeinu waited until right before his death to rebuke klal yisroel. Yet in the very next Rashi, Rashi writes that the reason Moshe waited was because he needed to prove to them first that he did something for them – leading them to battle and winning.
a.    How can we reconcile this with the previous Rashi?
b.    How could we understand this? Didn’t Moshe already lead them in a war against Amalek and defeat them? Also, there were many things that Moshe rabbeinu did for B’nei Yisroel in the midbar, in fact there was pretty much nothing he didn’t do. So why was entering and winning a battle necessary for Moshe to become “ood enough” to rebuke B’nei Yisroel? 

Friday, July 21, 2017

Parshas Mattos-Masei - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
מטות  פרשת 

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

1.    (31:3) If Hashem didn’t command to fulfill right away, why was it mutar for Moshe to do so?

2.    (31:7) Why did the tzitz specifically stop Billam and the kings of Midian from being able to fly?


3.    (31:7) How could witchcraft allow people to fly if in order to do kishuf one needs to be standing on the ground? (See Rashi Genara Sanhedrin 44b)

Thursday, July 13, 2017

Parshas Pinchas - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
 פנחספרשת 

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus


  1. (Rashi 26:46) Why did Sarach merit such a long life?
  2. (Rashi 27:22) Why did b’nos Telafchad wait so long to ask?
  3. (27:15) Rashi explains that Moshe demanded an answer/response from Hashem. Similarly, Rashi explains in Bamidbar 12:13 regarding Miriam. How could we understand Moshe’s more aggressive behavior at these particular points?
  4. (27:18) Hashem told Moshe that he should put his hand on Yehoshua and lean on him to give him s'meecha. However, the Torah accounts that Moshe leaned on Yehoshua with both his hands. How could Moshe add to the commandment of Hashem? Isn't that bal toseif?      

Friday, July 7, 2017

Parshas Balak - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
בלק   פרשת
Parsha Stumpers


By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (22:22) Why does the Torah describe Balak as “seeing” what B’nei Yisroel did as whereas by Yisro the Torah refers to Yisro’s “hearing”? What is the difference?

  1. (22:4) The Torah relates that Moav said to the elders of Midian that B’nei Yisroel will chew up their surroundings like an ox chews up its food. What was the point of this simile and why does the Torah feel the need to write it?

  1. (22:21) Why did Billam ride a donkey and not a horse?

  1. (22:28) Billam’s hit his donkey three times. When Hashem opened the donkey’s mouth, the first thing its first words to Billam was asking him, “What have I done to you that you have struck me these three times?”  Rashi writes that besides for giving Billam mussar, the donkey was also hinting to him that he will not be able to succeed in trying to uproot a nation which keeps the shalosh regalim. What is it about the shalosh regalim specifically which should be singled out as the best argument to Billam to convince him that he will fail?

  1. (Rashi 23:24) The Gemara in Berachos (14a) says that whoever says k'riyas shema without tefillin is like testifying false testimony on himself. With this is mind, there is a difficulty with a Rashi in this week's parsha. What is it? How could it be resolved?



Friday, June 30, 2017

Parshas Chukas - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת חקת

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. Rashi (19:22) writes that the parah adumah is a kapparah for the eigel ha'zahav – it is the mother cleaning after its baby. In fact, the Torah stresses six similarities between the parah adumah and eigel ha'zahav. What exactly is the connection, though, between mitzva of parah adumah and eigel haz'zahav (other than the fact that they are both cows) that it should be chosen to be its kaparah?

  1. (19:22) Why should the parah adumah cow act as a kapparah for the eigel? What about the concept of ein k’teigar na’aseh s’neiger – that the prosecutor does not become the defense counselor? (See Rashi 19:3 for example)

  1. Why is it that the eigel ha'zahav has no “settling of its debt”?

  1. The Torah states that the Parah Adumah had to be perfectly red. The Meforshim explain that even two black or white hairs would disqualify it from being a valid Parah Adumah. Why is it that two hairs disqualify it? If it needs to be perfect, shouldn't even one hair disqualify?

  1. Who does the Parah Adumah? In our Parsha – Elazar the S'gan Kohen (Aharon's son) performed the avodah, but it seems that that was only because Aharon couldn't since he was involved in the eigel hazahav. So whose job is it l'doros (I.e- from that point on)? Was it always the job of the S'gan Kohen or was it the job of the Kohen Gadol himself?

  1. Rashi (20:1) writes that the Torah puts Miriam's death next to parsha of parah adumah to show that the death of tzadikkim acts as a kapparah. How could we understand this concept?

  1. (20:2) Why because of Miriam did they merit water?

  1. (20:3) We find that B'nei Yisroel complained that they would have wished to remain in Mitzrayim. Yet, in “Dayeinu” on Pesach night we say if Hashem would have taken us out of Mitzrayim it would have been enough even without giving us the manna! What is it that we realize which the B'nei Yisroel of the time did not? And how could we be so sure to make such a claim?

  1. (Rashi 20:10) What is the connection between the places in the Torah when “something small contained something bigger”?

  1. (Rashi 20:12) Why just because B’nei Yisroel dealt with Eisav were they unsuccessful? And how could we understand that being attributed as a cause for Aharon’s death?

  1. (Rashi 20:25) Why would Hashem instruct Moshe to say this to Aharon? Granted it is encouraging for Aharon, but why weren’t Moshe’s feelings being considered?

  1. (Rashi 20:29) What had to be proven? Would B’nei Yisroel really think that Moshe killed Aharon? If he went up and didn’t come down and Moshe said that he died, what else would they think happened?

  1. (Rashi 21:1) Does t’fillah really work like that?

  1. Moshe rabbeinu was punished because of a lesson he failed to teach B'nei Yisroel by hitting the rock as opposed to speaking to it. What lesson (kal v'chomeir) was meant to be learned out? And why exactly would it have been a good lesson to learn from a mindless rock?

  1. Why did Hashem ask Moshe to take his stick if he wasn't supposed to hit the rock?

  1. Aharon got reprimanded along with Moshe during the episode of the hitting the rock – what did Aharon do wrong?

  1. Rashi (21:7) writes that we see from here that one should be quick to forgive. Why does Rashi first notice this here? What about all the other  times that Moshe davened on B’nei Yisroel’s behalf?

  1. (21:9) Was there something special about making the snake out of copper or was it in fact nothing more than a cute play on words from the hebrew word for snake – nachash?

  1. According to Rashi there is a word in this week’s parsha with a one letter shoresh. What is it? (Rashi 21:11)

  1. Rashi (21:32) explains that unlike the meraglim, the spies in this week’s parsha had no evil intentions and had complete faith in Hashem. If so why did they feel the need to spy?


  1. Rashi (21:34-35) writes that Moshe was afraid of a losing against Og because of a zechus that Og had. If Moshe was genuinely afraid because of the power of Og’s zechus, then how in fact did B’nei Yisroel win? And if it was really clear that Pg wouldn’t stand a chance because B’nei Yisroel were doing the right thing, then what was Moshe worries about originally?

Friday, June 23, 2017

Parshas Korach - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
 קרחפרשת 
Parsha Stumpers


By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. The medrash describes  that Korach approached Moshe and Aharon with two arguments:
-  “Does a talis  made completely of techeiles require a string of techeiles?”
- “Does a room full of sifrei Torah require a mezuza on its doorpost?”
                    a. What are the answers to these questions? Why?
                    b. What exactly was Korach getting at with this debate?
c. How do these “attacks” on Moshe and Aharon fit with Korach's motto of “ki kol ha'eidah kulam kedoshim u'vesocham Hashem” ?

  1. The Torah tells us that after Korach came to Moshe rabbeinu, Moshe fell on his face. There are three different types of “falling on the face” throughout Tanach. What are they?  When do they occur?

  1. Did Korach die? How did he die?

  1. a. Why was Moshe so insistent that Korach die in a weird way?
b. Didn't he know the mishna in Avos which says that the pit to swallow up Korach was already created?
c. How could Moshe ask Hashem that if such a creation was not made, that he should make it? Hashem created things yeis mei'ayin only during the time of Beraishis, why would Hashem make an exception now?