Friday, June 16, 2017

Parshas Shelach - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת שלח

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (13:2) Rashi writes that the story of the Meraglim was placed in the Torah immediately following the episode of Miriam because they did not learn from Miriam about how one should speak. Miriam spoke lashon harah about her brother, Moshe Rabbeinu, while the Meraglim spoke about Eretz Yisroel – an inanimate object, not a person. There is nothing wrong with doing so. So what did the Meraglim do wrong that they should have learned from the story of Miriam?

  1. (13:3) Rashi comments based on the passuk that the Torah considers Moshe’s sending the spies as by “the word of Hashem” because since Hashem did not prevent Mpshe from doing so, it must be as if he had permission. How could Rashi be so sure? Did Hashem stop Moshe from hitting the rock? Or from B’nei Yisroel from worshipping the eigel ha’zahav? Hashem allows us to have bechira (free choice). So why here just because Hashem did not stop something from happening does it suddenly necessarily mean that it must have been as if with full permission?

  1. (13:20) Rashi writes that “tree” refers to someone who has a zechus. Why is such a person referred to as a tree?

  1. (13:23) Why did the meraglim bring a whole cluster of grapes?

  1. (13:26) Rashi writes that just as the meraglim came back withan evil scheme, so too was the onset of their journey with an evil scheme. How could Rashi say this if in 13:3 Rashi explained that they were all anashim – men who were righteous?

  1. (13:30) How could Kalev even pretend to be part of the meraglim and oppose Moshe? Is this allowed – to “fake sinking to a lower level” in order to do a greater good?

  1. (13:33) The passuk says that the meraglim said that they felt like grasshoppers and so were they in the giants’ eyes. Rashi elaborates and writes that the meraglim said that they heard the giants saying “There are ants in the vineyards which look like men.” So which was it? Were they like grasshoppers or ants?

  1. (14:11) Rashi elaborates Hashem’s “argument” that the meraglim should have known better, especially having experienced the multitude of miracles in mitzrayim and the midbar. Indeed, it is quite a valid point! How could it be that the incredible miracles were so quick to be forgotten?


  1. Calev and Yehoshua each had the help of a tefillah to stay away from the plot of the meraglim. Why was this necessary? Why not just stay away?

  1. After the report of the Meraglim, the B'nei Yisroel cried out, “Why is Hashem bringing us to this land to fall by the sword? Our wives and young will be taken captive! Is it not better that we return to Egypt?” What were the B'nei Yisroel thinking? How exactly were they thinking they would be treated if they went back to Mitzrayim? Wouldn't this be what would happen regardless?

  1. (14:12) The Gemara in Berachos says that Hashem wanted to wipe out B'nei Yisroel in the desert and start fresh with only the descendants of Moshe. Moshe responded, “If a chair with three legs (Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov) cannot stand, then certainly a chair with one leg (just Moshe) cannot stand.” What was this argument? First of all, Moshe was also a descendant of Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. Second, even if not, perhaps Moshe is a super three part combo?

  1. (14:22) Hashem told Moshe that since the B'nei Yisroel left Mitzrayim, they tested Hashem 10 times. What were these 10 times?

  1. (14:13, 16) If Hashem was considering wiping out B’nei Yisroel, how could Moshe argue back that doing so would be a chillul Hashem? If Hashem wants to do it, then by definition how could it be a chilul Hashem?

  1. (14:33 Rashi explains that the generation of the meraglim all died in the desert by age 60. This is why the B'nei Yisroel had to remain there for 40 years – in order that the youngest (counted) ones among them, who were 20, would reach the age of 60. The Mefarshim explain that the reason for this was because they were not guilty of meesa b'dei shamayim (death from heaven), which occurs at 60. If so, what was Hashem's original thought to wipe them out immediately? And why didn't Moshe respond with this argument?

  1. (14:33) Rashi seems to say that the reason for the 40 years in the midbar had to do with clearing out the 20-60 generation before entering Eretz (14:33) Rashi seems to say that the reason for the 40 years in the midbar had to do with clearing out the 20-60 generation before entering Eretz  Yisroel. How could we reconcile this with Rashi earlier (13:25) which attributes the 40 years as being a punishment – one year for each day the meraglim toured Eretz Yisroel?


  1. When Moshe davened on behalf of B'nei Yisroel in this week's parsha, he used only about half of the 13 middos. Why?

  1. (14:41-45) – Why did they leave despite Moshe’s warning? What was lacking in their logic? Why isn’t this Bitachon?

  1. There are 3 ways that the mission of the meraglim was described: 1. Hashem in our parsha calls it “v'yasuru” 2. B'nei Yisroel call it “V'yachp'ru” (Devarim 1:22) and 3. The meraglim said “v'yarg'lu. What is the difference between these three expressions and perspectives?

  1. (15:41) – Rashi writes the reason for the color of techeiles on the tzitizis was to serve as a reminder of makas b’choros and that th8 strings correspond to the 8 days between laving mitzrayim and singing az yashir after crossing the Yam Suf. How could this be reconciled with the classic explanation that the techeils comes from the sea which is a reflection of the sky to serve as a reminder to fear Hashem?


  1. (Haftorah) How do you know Kohanim could become invisible? (No cheating – don't ask a Kohen)

Thursday, June 8, 2017

Parshas Beha'aloscha - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
בהעלתך פרשת   
Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (8:2) Rashi explains that Hashem told Aharon, “Your role is greater than theirs...” The Torah in parshas Nasso goes through great lengths to tell us that all the karbanos of the n'si'im were equal in the eyes of Hashem. Why suddenly by Aharon must it be that his be more precious?


  1. (8:4) Rashi reminds us of the complexity of the Menorah. Why did Hashem command to make a vessel impossible to comprehend how to construct? And why specifically the menorah?

  1. (8:4) Rashi mentions that the Menorah was banged and hammered. I thought there was no hammering in the beis hamikdash / mishkan because they used the shamir worm?

  1. (8:6) Rashi elaborates that Hashem commanded Moshe before preparing the levi’im for their avodah to “take them with words” i.e – offer encouraging words by telling them how fortunate they are for being chosen to help serve Hashem in a special way. Why couldn’t the Levi’im understand and appreciate this on their own?

  1. (8:24) Rashi writs that physical blemishes do not disqualify a Levi, even though they are disqualifications for a kohen. Why the difference?

  1. (9:1) Why was this the only Karbon Pesach that the B'nei Yisroel brought while in the desert? And if there was a valid reason for this, then why does Rashi refer to it as a discredit to B'nei Yisroel?

  1. (9:6) Rashi writes that when B'nei Yisroel wanted to know about bringing a make-up karbon pesach, it must be that they asked only Moshe and not Aharon because how would it be possible for Aharon to have known something that Moshe didn't. How could that be the reason that Rashi is so sure. The Torah itself tells us the story of Pinchas when he “reminded” Moshe of a halacha. And the Gemara describes certain tana'im who were me'cha'deish chidushin. So why is the fact that Aharon was Moshe's student a valid proof that he must have known less?

  1. (9:10) Why is karbon pesach so unique that those who miss it receive a second chance unlike any other mitzva?

  1. (10:2) Why were the trumpets that Moshe blew considered a separate “kol”?

  1. (10:7) When was Morse code really invented? And was this “Morse code” a mere code or were the length of the sounds and sequence of lengths intrinsically significant?

  1. (10:29) The passuk refers to Yisro as Chovav – which was one of his seven names. Rashi explains that he was called Chovav because of his love for the Torah. Of all people in the Torah to be called Chovav for his love of Torah why would it be Yisro? What about Moshe? Aharon? The Zekainim? Also, who gave him this nickname?

  1. (10:35) The Torah interrupts the chain of events in this week’s parsha with an unrelated fact about the travels of B’nei Yisroel through the midbar. Rashi writes that the Torah does this specifically to make a separation between two derogatory stories. What is this concept? What is the point of interruptions if that is not the sequence of events. Granted the Torah is not a history book, but who are we trying to fool by specifically interrupting the “story” with an irrelevant piece of information?

  1. (10:36) Rashi comments that we see that the shechina only comes to rest on B'nei Yisroel when there are 22,000 people. What about the gemara berachos and the mishnayos in pirkei avos which describe that the shechina comes to rest on 10 people → even 3 → even 2 → even 1?

  1. (11:1) The Torah describes that those who complained and sinned amongst B'nei Yisroel were “like those who seek pretenses...” why 'like'? They were people who were trying to stir up trouble?

  1. (11:15) The Torah quotes Moshe as saying, “And if this is how You will deal with me, then kill me now”. Rashi puts this into context by explaining that Hashem showed Moshe the punishment he was going to inflict on B’nei Yisroel to which Moshe responded, “If that is what you will do then kill me first!” Moshe was just speaking to Hashem, Who was clearly “upset” with B’nei Yisroel. So what was Moshe trying to accomplish by saying this ‘heroic line’? Who was he trying to impress?

  1. (11:22) What exactly was the conversation between Hashem and Moshe?

  1. (11:26) The Sanhedrin of Zekainim were chosen by means of lottery with the understanding that clearly Hashem does not want those who did not win. There were a number of significant lotteries done in the midbar and mishkan/beis hamikdash. How could we understand this approach of use of “happenstance and luck” to decide such important matters? What is different about this and what the rishonim refer to in other places as darchei ha’emori (superstition)?

  1. (12:13) Rashi lists four places where Moshe asked Hashem what would be. What is the connection between these four things which caused Moshe to more aggressively ask about their outcomes?

  1. (12:13) Moshe davened a very short tefillah for his sister in order for people not to accuse him of caring more for her than everyone else. Would anyone really be so inconsiderate to accuse Moshe of such a thing? He was davening for his sister?!


Friday, June 2, 2017

Parshas Nasso - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
נשא    פרשת  

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. Why is the parsha of sotah so serious that based on suspicion we give her to drink from the bitter waters to determine whether she is guilty? We do not find this by other aveiros. For example, one who we suspect killed someone else, there is no potion to give him to determine his guilt, rather he is innocent until 2 witnesses come and go through the long process of demonstrating that their story is true and that the man is guilty?

  1. Rashi (7:11) writes that Moshe did not know which order the n'si'im should bring their offerings: if it should be in age-order or in order of their travels. Why was Moshe unsure though, Hashem had not yet commanded Moshe the order of their travels so that should not have even been an option?

  1. Why does the Torah repeat each karbon brought for each of the nasi'im? They are exactly the same! Why not just write it once and say that this is what each nasi brought?

  1. The karbanos that the nasi'im brought consisted of a young bull, one ram, one sheep, and one he-goat. Rashi writes that the bull corresponds to Avraham, the ram corresponds to Yitzchak, and the sheep corresponds to Yaakov. The he-goat is to atone for the selling of Yosef.
a. What place does the goat for the atonement of Yosef have here?
b. Not all the shevatim were involved in the sale of Yosef – and certainly not Ephraim and Menashe who themselves come from Yosef? So Why was this a universal karbon for all the nasi'im?

  1. Rashi (7:85) learns from the passuk that all the implements in the Beis Hamikdash were precise in their weight such as whether one would weigh them one by one or weigh them all together he would never find a discrepancy. What is Rashi coming to teach us? Obviously the collective sum of all the weights will always equal taking each weight separately and adding them together?
         



Thursday, May 25, 2017

Parshas Bamidbar - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
במדבר f. פרשת 
Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus


  1. Rashi (1:2) writes that the way Moshe counted B'nei Yisroel was through collecting a half-shekel per person. Why did he have count them like this?
  2. The passuk tells us that the people had to establish their genealogy according to their families. Rashi explains that they each brought documents of lineage and witnesses of their birth in order to precisely trace each one's ancestry. Why was this necessary? Why not just believe them in the first place? 
  3. What is the significance of a flag?
  4. (5:1) Rashi notes that the passuk refers to Elazar and Isamar as the children of Aharon and Moshe – Aharon because he was their biological father, and Moshe because he was their rebbe. However, in the following passuk (3:2) it repeats and only calls them the sons of Aharon. 
  5. Why should being someone's rebbe make one considered his father?
  6. Why is the passuk switching in the next passuk to just call them the sons of Aharon?
  7. (3:16) When it came to counting shevet Levi, Rashi (2:16) comments that Moshe did not know what to do. He said, “How can I enter the tents to know the number of their nursing infants?” Hashem replied, “You go outside the tent and I will let you know the number of who is in which tent.” 
  8. If Hashem was going to tell him through a bas-kol how many were in each tent, why did Moshe have to go up to the tents to begin with?
  9. Why did this only first become an issue when it came to counting shevet Levi?
  10. When it came to counting B'nei Yisroel, the Torah tells us that only those that were at least 20 years old were counted whereas at the end of the parsha when it came to counting shevet Kehas, they were counted starting at 30. Rashi in each place comments based on the words the Torah uses to describe the specific ages that we learn from here that the age of going out to war is 20, and the age of strength is 30. What is the significance of this and why were they counted based on these two different scales?                                                                                   
  11. Why do we eat dairy on Shavuos?

Thursday, May 18, 2017

Parshas Behar-Bechukosai - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
בחקותי פרשת 

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus


  1. If the highest level of avodas Hashem is doing mitzvos lishmah, then why is it that in this pasha the Torah tells us that if “bechukosai teileichu”…then Hashem will give rain…?
  2. Once the Torah did in fact choose to describe the rewards of those who walk in the way of Hashem, why choose the “minor leagues” of the rewards of this world as opposed to the major league rewards of Olam Haba’ah?

Friday, May 5, 2017

Acharei Mos-Kedoshim

~ Something to Think About ~
 אחרי-מות פרשת 

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. Rashi 16:1 – Why necessary to spook Aharon out here by this mitzva more than anyone else by any other? And why Aharon more than anyone else? He understood right away with “va'yidom aharon ” that his children deserved to die?

  1. Rashi 16:5 – Why would merely changing the clothes require tevilas yadayim v'raglaim?

  1. 16:8 – Why were the two goats chosen via lottery arbitrarily to decide which one was la'hashem and which la'a'za'zel?

  1. 17:10 The passuk (17:10) when describing prohibition of eating blood says that anyone who eats blood – Hashem will direct his face upon them and cut them off from their people. Rashi explains further that Hashem will turn aside, so to speak, from all his other concerns to deal with this person. What is so bad about eating blood that the Torah takes so seriously? (Extra Credit: Where else in the Torah does the Torah use the same expression and Rashi explain the same way? What is the connection?)

  1. The Gemara in Yoma says that the picking of which goat was “for Hashem” and which was to go “to Azazel” was determined solely by the lot they had. Rashi in Parshas Kedoshim, though, explains the issur of “lo sinachshu” and “lo s'oneinu” (not to practice divination; and not to believe in luck) as viewing arbitrary events as meaningful omens. If one is not supposed to believe in luck or arbitrary outcomes, why is it that we use a lottery to determine which goat should be used on Yom Kippur as an offering to Hashem and which should go to its death in Azazel?



Thursday, April 27, 2017

Parshas Tazria-Metzora - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~

פרשת תזריע

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (12:3) ”Rashi writes that just like man was created after animals, so too were the halachos of birth commanded after halachos of animals (kashrus).” Indeed sometimes the Torah instructs us that the proper order of teaching and responding is A-B A-B: That when two things are said the proper approach is to respond in the same order (See also when Eliezer responded to Lavan/Besuel). However there are also examples where the Torah orders in a A-B B-A format justifying that since the last thing taught is still fresh on the mind we respond to that first. (See Gemara Berachos 2a and Tosfos Bava Kamma 17a). What are the guidelines when to respond in the order of things mentioned and when to respond to the second item first?

  1. (13:14) Rashi writes that when a person thinks he has tzara’as he must go to the kohen have it inspected. However, there are two exceptions: A chossen (during sheva berachos) and any person on a Yom Tov. How could we understand this? Why would the Torah push aside a pressing matter for personal happiness? Clearly the person deserves the tzara’as so why consider the fact that the afflicted will suffer on his “personal days”? It’s his own fault!

  1. Tzara’as is a physical effect of something non-physical (harmful speech). The truth is that all speech creates realities. Where is that hinted to in the Hebrew word for “speech” and where do we hint to this idea in davening?
  

~ Something to Think About ~

פרשת מצורע

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. Where is there an acronym for Motzee Shem Ra in this week's parsha?

  1. (14:4) The Rambam writes (Mishna Torah and Shemoneh Perakim) that one who has failed in a particular middah and now wants to work on fixing it, should first balance it out by going to the other extreme. So, for example, one who had become a big ba’al gaivah and want to now work on suppressing his ego and becoming more humble, he should do things on the opposite extreme of what he had been doing until he is able to find the proper balance in the middle. If so, granted the hyssop is very necessary as part of the metzora’s tahara as Rashi explains, but why the cedarwood? Shouldn’t that specically be left out?

  1. Rabbah bar bar Shila says on Daf Beis amud beis in Berachos that if in the passuk of “u'va ha'shemesh v'taheir”, u'va hashemesh=beeas ohro and v'taheir=tahor gavra; then the passuk should have used the word “vayitaheir” to illustrate the active requirement to become tahor instead of the word “tahor” which is a more passive sounding word (even without a kaparah).....Ask a question on this from this week's parsha.

  1. (14:34) Why is tzara’as also Hashem’s method of letting people know when there are treasures behind the wall of a house?