Thursday, October 15, 2015

Parshas Noach - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~

פרשת נח


Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus
                                              A Riddle:
    סוף סוף ראשי     1.
  תחילת סוף סופי     
    ויבא נח...אל התבה      
            מי אני?ג    

  1. (6:9) Where is there a remez in the beginning of the parsha that Noach was not involved in any of these three things?

  1. (6:9) Rashi brings down an opinion that Noach was only great compared to those who lived in his generation, but had he lived in Avraham’s generation he wouldn’t have been anything remarkable. Why would we compare an individual to others? All that should matter was if Noach was righteous based on expectations of him alone, not based on what others are capable of?

  1. (6:13) How could the dor ha'mabul be punished if there were no mitzvos yet? [Chizkuni]

  1. (6:13) Rashi writes that because of the zenus of the generation, the gezairah (decree) was that all mankind – good and bad – were to die. Why should the good people be swept along with the bad?

  1. (6:13) Rashi says that despite all the things that the dor ha'mabbul were doing, the gezairah was sealed because of robbery. Why robbery more than avodah zarrah or giluy arayos?

  1. (6:14) Why did Hashem have Noach building the teivah specifically for 120 years and no more or less?

  1. (6:14) According to Chizkuni that there was a miracle that the tar on the outside didn’t get burned, why couldn’t Hashem allow Noach’s teivah to be like Moshe’s with only tar on the outside and double-dip on the already necessary neis for either the outer tar not to get ruined in the hot water or for the protective layer of cold water whyich surrounded the teivah to separate it from the boiling water?

  1. (6:17) Why did Hashem punish the world through means of a mabbul of water?

  1. (6:18) Rashi emphasizes the two parts of the “bris” with Noach as a promise to keep the food from spoiling and to protect him from the people who would try to kill him.
a. Why was the promise only needed to ensure that the food stay good in the teivah?
b. Didn’t Hashem on His own want to stop the people who dared threaten Noach (as Rashi says in 7;17)?

  1. (7:2) Even if Noach needed to bring Karbanos after surviving the mabbul, why were 7 pairs of each kosher animal necessary?

  1. (7:4) Why does Rashi refer to the children of the adulterous unions at the time of the mabbul as “mamzeirim”? Isn’t that specifically if the parents are Jewish?

  1. (7:7) Rashi both in 6:18 and 7:7 writes that it was forbidden to have marital relations in the teivah. However, Rashi in 7:7 adds that the reason for this was because the world was in a state of distress...
(a) Why does Rashi repeat himself?  (b) Why does Rashi in 7:7 add the reason? (c ) Why is this a valid reason? Clearly the people dying in the mabbul deserved it. Shouldn't it have been considered a “joyous” time for the world?

  1. (7:12) Where do we see from this week's parsha that the day starts at night? Why is it that there is a concept of miktzas hayom k'kulo only if the night is part of the “miktzas”, yet if have even the full day without the preceding night, this concept is not applicable?

  1. (7:17) The Torah uses the phrase בעצם היום הזה in this week's parsha as well as three other times in chumash in the same way. Where are these four times [Beraishis 7:17 ; Beraishis 17:37 ; Shemos 12:21 ; Devarim 32:48] and what is the connection between them?

  1. (7:17-20 and 8:4) The teivah was submerged 11 amos and the water came above the highest mountains by 15 amos. It comes out that there was always a minimum of 4 amos between the bottom of the teivah and the ground. Why was this necessary? Do these 4 amos have a particular significance?

  1. (7:23) Why did Og get Saved? How did he survive being outside of the teivah?

  1. (7:23) Rashi writes that about Noach it is written (Mishlei 11:31), “Behold the righteous one is paid [punished] on earth” referring to the fact that he was bitten by the lion in the teivah. What was he punished for?

  1. (8:7) Why did Noach send out the raven and the dove? Why not just trust that Hashem would tell him when to come out of the teivah?

  1. (8:8) Why did Noach assume that if the dove found land that it wouldn’t return the teivah where its species was?

  1. (8:10-11) The passukim describe that the second time Noach sent out the dove, it came back with an olive branch in its mouth. Rashi comments that the dove was trying to tell Noach the following: “Better let my food be bitter as an olive and provided by the hand of Hashem, and not sweet as honey but provided by the hand of man...” (a) The dove should have had hakaras hatov to Noach and his family. Why at the first opportunity does the dove say such a remark? (b ) The dove's statement makes absolutely no sense! The entire time Noach and the animals were in the teivah they experienced open miracles. The whole teivah was something which opposed teva. Wasn't it pretty apparent that Hashem was present every step of the way?

  1. (8:14) Rashi writes that the world needed a complete solar year of destruction, yet Rashi said earlier (7:12 #2) that the first day didn’t count because it wasn’t a complete day without the night before. If so, how was there a complete year of destruction?

  1. (8:21) Surely Hashem knew even before the mabbul that people are bad from youth. So, either way – if that’s not a reason to destroy the world then why did Hashem destroy it? And if it is a valid reason then why never again? What changed? Also, what is the connection between this “decision” and the fact that it seems to have been decided as a result of Hashem “smelling” the re’ach hane’choach of Noach’s offering?

  1. (9:1) Why did Hashem need to give Noach a beracha that the animals would fear him? Wasn't this already built into the world from the sheishes y'mei beraishis?

  1. (9:9) Why did Hashem approve of Noach’s necessity to demand a bris if Hashem had commanded him already to have children in 9:1?

  1. (9:24) How did Noach know it was Cham who dishonored him?

  1. (9:25) Did Noach do the right thing by cursing Cna'an?

  1. (9:25-26) Why did Noach have to curse Cham’s children to be slaves to his brother, and also bless Shem that Cham be his slaves? Wouldn’t one of these be enough?

  1. (11:1) One of the reasons Rashi gives as the reason behind why the dor haflaga began to build the tower is because they thought that the world was on a cycle that every 1656 years Hashem wold bring another flood, so they wanted to be prepared with supports for the skies. If so, why was Hashem so upset? Why not just let the people think this incorrectly as long as they aren't bothering anyone?

  1. If the dor haflaga wanted to 'wage war' with Hashem, why did they buildמגדל  בבל  in a valley? They should have built it on top of a mountain!?


  1. (11:28) Rashi brings down the story from the famous medrash how Haran (Avraham's brother) stood and observed the episode of Avraham being thrown into the fiery furnace. Haran decided that Avraham's fate would determine his own faith in Hashem. The medrash continues that indeed when Avraham emerged unscathed, Haran joined his side and was consequentially thrown into the fire – and burned to death. What did Haran do wrong? The Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo writes that Hashem does not perform miracles for every kofeir that decides not to believe in Hashem. This is why we have t he Torah and mitzvos which direct us to remember Yetziyas Mitzrayim and Kriyas Yam Suf as a forever certificate of Hashem's capabilities. Haran obviously lived before matan Torah and kriyas yam suf, so what was so bad with him wanting to see Hashem perform an open miracle first before fully believing in Hashem? 

Friday, October 9, 2015

Parshas Beraishis - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת בראשית

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

1.     (1:1) The Torah begins with “Beraishis bara Elokim”. Why not start with “Elokim bara beraishis” which would (a). Allow the first letter of the Torah be an ‘aleph’, (b). allow the first word to be the name of Hashem and (c). not cause any possible misunderstanding in someone chas v’shalom thinking that something called “beraishis” created Hashem?

2.    (1:1) Rashi writes that it is important to start the Torah with a recount of Hashem being the master and creator because this way it is clear to the goyim that Hashem has the only right to decide who gets Eretz Yisroel – the B’nei Yisroel. If we are counting on the goyim accepting the story of the Torah, then for the same price it should be enough for them to just read that Hashem promised us Eretz Yisroel without going into detail of days of Beraishis. So how did Rashi answer his question? Furthermore, what good did it do? Still our enemies try to take Eretz Yisroel from us and claim it for themselves? So what good did it do to put the story of beraishis first in the Torah?

3.    Rashi (1:1) writes that both Yisroel and Torah are called “reishis”. What else is referred to as such and what is the connection between them?

4.    What was the first thing created?

5.    The mishna mentions a number of things which were created both before beraishis and right before Shabbos. What is unique about these things that they were created on the bookends of the six days of creation?

6.    What is the “logic” and “reasoning” behind the order of when everything was created?

7.    (1:5) Rashi comments that angels were created on the 2nd day of Creation. Why at that particular point?

8.    (1:8) Rashi describes that shamayim (heavens) is made of eish (fire) and mayim (water). What does that mean?

9.    (1:11) Rashi explains that the trees did not listen to the commandment of Hashem. (a) How could they not listen, they are just trees!? (b) Why could they only get punished once man sinned?

10. (1:12) Rashi writes that the vegetables made a kal v’chomeir based on what the trees were commanded. What exactly was the kal v’chomeir? And how could the greens be so sure of the kal v’chomeir? Hashem was creating the world for the first time; maybe His rules for trees would not apply to vegetables?

11.  (1:16) Rashi relates that the moon complained that there cannot be two rulers over the same domain. As a result, Hashem reduced its size. Was the moon incorrect?

12. (1:26) The passuk uses the phrase “let us make man”, which Rashi explains was Hashem’s expression of humility that He – so to speak – consulted with the angels. This was done deliberately to teach this lesson of humility despite the tremendous risk of people possibly reading the Torah and be misled to believe that there was more than One Creator. Was it really worth this risk? Certainly a better place could be found to demonstrate Hashem’s humility without risking such a possibility?

13. How many mitzvos did Adom have?

14. (2:15) The passuk (2:9) says that Hashem put an eitz ha’da’as as well as an eitz ha’chaim in gan eden. Yet Hashem only warned Adom not to eat from eitz ha’da’as. Was he allowed to eat from eitz ha’chaim? Did he? What would have happen if ate from both?

15. (2:17) Hashem warned Adom that the day that he would eat from eitz ha’da’as that he would die. So why is it that on the day that Adom ate from the eitz ha’da’as he did not die?

16. (2:18) If Chava was not yet created at the time of the commandment not to eat from the eitz ha’da’as, then why was she held responsible for not keeping the commandment?

17. (3:3) Rashi seems to understand that the disaster of the eitz ha’da’as had a lot to do with the fact that Chava added that Hashem told them not to touch the eitz ha’da’as, when in reality all that Hashem said was not to eat from the eitz ha’da’as. How is this any different, though, from that which we learn in the first mishna in Avos – that one should make for himself a protective fence around the Torah’s mitzvos? We have many mitzvos m’d’rabanan (from the Rabbis) as a fence to the Torah. Why was what Chava did any worse?

18. (3:19) The Kitzur Shulchan Aruch states that it is dangerous for one to eat sweat, with the exception of sweat from one’s face. Where is there a remez in this week’s parsha for this?


19. (4:1) There seems to be a progressive pattern of usage of Hashem’s Name throughout parshas Beraishis. During the sheishes y’mei beraishis and description of the first shabbos “va’yechulu…”, Hashem is referred to only as Elokim. From that point until and including Adom and Chava being thrown out of Gan Eden, Hashem is referred to as Hashem Elokim. Then, for the first time, after Adom and Chava give birth to their first son, Chava named him Kayin as she said, “I have acquired (ka’nee’see) a man with G-d – for the first time referring to Him as only Hashem. From that point on, Hashem is referred to as just Hashem. Why the differences and what is the significance and connection of the times that the changes occurred to the names of Hashem?

Friday, October 2, 2015

Parshas V'zos Beracha - Parsha Stumper

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת וזאת הברכה
Parsha Stumpers


By: Daniel Listhaus

1.     Rashi brings from Sifrei and gemara (Avodah Zarrah 2b) that Hashem first offered the Torah to Eisav and Yishmael, but they both rejected it and finally He gave the Torah to B’nei Yisroel. What does this mean? Were we a “last resort” or just part of a list of nations Hashem went down until He got to us and we accepted it so we were the “last place Hashem looked”?

2.    During the berachos in parshas V’zos Ha’beracha, Moshe refers to Shevet Gad as being compared to a lion (33:20), as well as Shevet Dan (33:22). Why is this different from birkas Yaakov?

3.    Rashi (34:5) brings a machlokes regarding who physically wrote the remaining few passukim of the Torah after it declares Moshe’s death. One opinion is that Yehoshua wrote it, the other opinion maintains that Moshe wrote the remaining part as well with tears i.e- crying as he wrote it (see Bava Basra 15a). The reason for this opinion is because how is it possible for the Torah to have been incomplete during Moshe’s lifetime. How would the other opinion respond?

4.    Rashi (34:6) brings from the mishna in Avos (5:6) which states that Moshe rabbeinu’s burial place was one of the things created during the six days of creation. In truth this is a machlokes in that mishna. The question is though, what is so special about Moshe’s burial place that it should among the things created during the first erev shabbos during bein has’mashos (twilight)? Also, according to the one who holds that indeed Moshe’s burial place was created at that time – outside Eretz Yisroel – then it must have been planned already that Moshe rabbeinu was not to enter Eretz Yisroel. We know that Moshe was not allowed in because of his own “sin” so how does the mishna fit with the concept of bechira (free choice)?

5.    Rashi (34:7) learns from the passuk that Moshe’s eyes did not dim even after his death. Somehow, Rashi understands that Moshe retained perfect vision not only during his lifetime but after death as well. What does this mean?

6.    Rashi (34:8) sees from the passuk that at the time of Moshe’s death then men felt much more emotionally tied to Moshe as opposed to by Aharon’s death when the sorrow was felt equally by men and women. Rashi explains that the reason for this difference is because Aharon was someone who brought peace between man and wife. How could we understand this Rashi? Surely the women should have realized that Moshe did just as much for them – from leading them out of Mitzrayim and through the midbar. So why didn’t they express the same sorrow?

7.    Rashi (34:12) writes that Moshe’s “strong hand” was evident from his ability to carry down the luchos, which as the Sifsei Chochomim points out, were very heavy. However, didn’t the luchos carry themselves?


8.    As a general rule, we do not like ending topics on a “bad note” dealing with bad times (puraniyus) in B’nei Yisroel, yet Rashi seems compelled to explain the very last passuk of the Torah as a reference to Moshe smashing the luchos during the time of the eigel ha’zahav, as opposed to explaining it as still referring to the wonders of Mitzrayim continuing the theme from the previous passuk. Why?

Friday, September 25, 2015

Parshas Ha'azinu - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת האזינו

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (32:2) Rashi explains that the Torah gives the simile of Torah being like dew as opposed to rain because rain is annoying to people as opposed to dew which everyone is happy with. Rashi gives two examples of how rain is annoying to some people: It is annoying when one is trying to travel and it is annoying for someone who has an uncovered barrel of wine. Why does Rashi feel it is necessary to give any example at all, let alone two of them

  1. (32:9) Rashi describes that Avraham + Yitzchak + Yaakov with the qualities they represented are like three strands of string twisted together into a strong rope. Similarly we find in the Gemara Berachos when Moshe was fighting on B’nei Yisroel’s behalf and davening that Hashem not wipe them out. Moshe said that unlike his own descendents which would only have him – a “one legged stool” – to rely on, B’nei Yisroel are backed by a “three legged chair” of Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. Assuming that Moshe Rabbeinu, who was worthy of receiving the Torah and leading B’nei Yisroel, had the same qualities, is there something stronger of the middos being represented specifically by three different individuals as opposed to one person containing all three?


  1. (32:48) Rashi points out that there are three times in the Torah where the Torah uses the expression of “b’etzem ha’haom ha’zeh”. However, in truth there are four. What is the one which Rashi leaves out and why does he do so?

Friday, September 18, 2015

Parshas Vayeilech - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת וילך

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. “Vayeilech Moshe...” Where did Moshe go?

  1. (31:1) The S'forno and others explain that Moshe said to B'nei Yisroel, “ I am old and no longer able to go and come back...and even if I was able to, still Hashem said to me that I anyway cannot enter into Eretz Yisroel.” What was the point of the first half of Moshe's statement? Let him just say that Hashem said he cannot enter Eretz Yisroel? How was this different from Yaakov’s response to Pharoah when asked how old he was?

  1. (31:1) How did Moshe know when he was going to die?

  1. What is significant about dying on the same day one is born?

  1. There are many differences between what Hashem told Yeshoshua and what Moshe told Yehoshua. What are these differences? And why the differences?

  1. Rashi (31:12) says that the men come to hakhel to learn, the women to hear, and the children to give reward to those who brought them. What does this mean?

  1. The passuk (31:14) says “hein karvo yame'cha lamus”. The simple way to understand the passuk is “Behold, your days are drawing near to die...” However, as a remez, the word “hein” – represented by the letters hey and nun – could also actually refer to Moshe rabbeinu. How is this?

  1. (31:29) Rash, in an answer to a question of his, writes that a rebbe considers his talmid like himself. If so, how did Rashi answer his question? If Yehoshua was considered to Moshe like Moshe himself, then it should follow that Yehoshua's talmid was viewed by Yehoshua as Yehoshua himself. The “chain rule” should then say that Moshe would consider even his talmid's talmid's talmid's talmid..... as himself. If so, how did Rashi answer his question?

  1. The Gemara Sanhedrin brings a proof from our parsha for techiyas hamaysim. What is it?

  1. (When parshas Vayeilech falls out on Shabbos Shuva): In the Haftorah for Shabbos Shuva we read, “Shuva Yisroel ad Hashem elo'kecha” (Repent, Yisroel, until Hashem your G-d). The choice of word to say “ad Hashem” instead of “l'Hashem” (to Hashem) seems a bit strange. What is hinted to in the passuk by writing it this way?


Thursday, September 10, 2015

Parshas Nitzavim - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת נצבים

Parsha Stumpers

By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. (29:13-14) The passukim  say, “Not with you alone do I forge this bris  and this oath, but with whoever is here, standing with us today before Hashem, our G-d, and with whoever is not here with us today…” How could a bris be made with people who are not present?

  1. (29:15) The passuk says,
 כִּי אַתֶּם יְדַעְתֶּם אֵת אֲשֶׁר יָשַׁבְנוּ בְּאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם וְאֵת אֲשֶׁר עָבַרְנוּ בְּקֶרֶב הַגּוֹיִם אֲשֶׁר עֲבַרְתֶּם
Why switch from “that which we passed” to “that which you passed”

  1. (29:28)There are nekudos (dots) above certain letters/words in the passuk. Why is this and why over those particular ones?

  1. (30:12) The Rosh and Da’as Zekainim mention that there is a remez in the passuk that in the zechus of bris millah, Moshe was able to enter shamayim. Which zechus millah is being referred to? And why this particular zechus?

  1. (30:19) Rashi writes that “Hashem tells us to look at the sun, which obeys Hashem command perfectly – it rises and sets every day at the right time, even though it will not receive any reward for doing so. Therefore, certainly we who will get reward for listening to Hashem should do so...” How could we understand this Rashi? There is a very simple pircha with this kal v'chomer: the sun is an inanimate object with no ability to think or decide, nor does it have any nesyonos to stop it. So how could it be so obvious that we should be expected to obey Hashem as well as the sun?




Friday, September 4, 2015

Parshas Ki Savo - Parsha Stumpers

~ Something to Think About ~
פרשת כי תבא
Parsha Stumpers


By: Daniel Listhaus

  1. Why is it that upon the time of bringing bikkurim is the proper time to say the whole tefillah of history starting from Lavan and Yaakov? What is the connection to bikkurim? And why must it be said to the kohen as opposed to one saying it to himself in the field?

  1. (26:1) The Mishna in Bikkurim (1:4) states that a ger (convert) brings bikkurim but cannot be korei (read) the paragraph which is recited because he is not able to say “l'a'voseinu” since his ancestors were not Jewish. If so, why is it that a ger could say “elokeinu v'elokei avoseinu” in shemoneh esreh? [Peirosh Ha’Rosh]

  1. (26:8) There is a passuk in this week's parsha with a remez to the five seforim of the Torah. Which passuk is it? What are the remazim? And how do they hint to their respective sefer they are hinting to? [Ohr Hachaim]

  1. (28:6) In the passuk of “baruch ata b'vo'echa...” Rashi explains that just as one enters the world pure and without sins, so too will one leave the world with no sin. However, following this explanation, it should be that the meaning of the passuk in the to'che'cha of “arur ata b'vo'echa…” should mean that just as you were cursed coming into the world, so too will you be when you leave. How could this be true if everyone comes into the world pure? [Sifsei Chochomim]

  1. The Gemara in Ta'anis (2a) says that there are three keys that Hashem has which he doesn't give to a shli'ach. One is hinted to in this week's parsha...which is the one hinted to in this week's parsha? What are the other two? How could we resolve the fact that there are stories in tanach and gemara about individuals who seem to have had control over one (or more) of these keys?


  1. Why does the Torah write more K'lalos (curses) than berachos (blessings) if we know that Hashem rewards much more than punishes?